As an aspiring law student, the concept of English Common Law is very interesting to me. It's a very useful thing. If you don't know, it's a legal system basically where laws are made by judges, rather than parliaments or whatever. This is in contrast to Europe where their laws are very ridgid and set in stone. Over time, Common Law started being a system where jurists interpreted laws made by legislatures, as you can't legislate for every eventuality. Sometimes the rules are clear, and other times, not so much. The same thing applies to this forum. Sometimes the rules are clear, but other times they're not, and through interpreting the rules and applying it to different cases, we create new policies or precedents. We've already formed several new precedents since I took over in early October 2025, so this thread will serve as a central location of moderation posts and the precedents they set out. Note, not every moderation thread will be in here, as not all moderation post creates new policies or precedents. I just posted the first 8, but there are more. I will continue to update this thread.
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.
The Administration Will Not Tolerate Libel, Nor Will It Default To Mob Justice Date of Precedent: 3 October, 2025. Thread: Starting Over (Archive, Elten English Community) Context: After the forum was transferred to Sir-Charlie, discussions were ongoing regarding the future of the forum. During the discussion, several users leveled serious allegations against the user manny 0211 engaging in inappropriate behaviour with children. Sir-Charlie ruled that leveling serious accusations at fellow forum members without evidence (libel) was unacceptable and urged an immediate halt on the bullying against manny 0211. He further wrote that the Administration will not moderate based on populism.
Relevant quotes:
..Put simply, pedophilia is a serious offense that requires serious evidence to support such a serious claim, and, so far, I've seen none of that. I am requesting that, unless substancial evidence is brought forth to support the user Manny 0211 being implicated in the said acts, that attacks on him in that nature stop now. ..
.. We will not be tolerating bullying of any kind, not to mention libel in every semi-functional jurisdiction is a serious offense, and many of you, I suspect, may have crossed that threshold assuming evidence to the contrary is not forthcoming. ..
.. Everyone deserves a fair chance and a right to due process. At the end of the day, if we ban Manny 0211 because of illinformed community outrage today, it may just be you tomorrow. ..
.. Everyone deserves a fair chance and a right to due process. ..
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.
A Heated Thread Will Be Given The Opportunity To Calm Down Before Closing And, If The Thread Remains Civil and Ontopic, It May Remain Open Date of Precedent: 13 October, 2025 Thread Name: Clone or not a clone (Archive, Elten English Community) Context: A thread was created to discuss if certain games were in fact unauthorised forks, commonly referred to as clones. After a while the thread became heated as some users resorted to personal attacks. Sir-Charlie intervened in Post 68, where he ruled the thread would be allowed to stay open, providing the thread remained respectful and stayed on topic. The thread was closed 3 days later on 16 October, due to the thread becoming hostile once again after a temporary lull.
Relevant Quotes:
.. I'll allow the thread to stay open with the understanding that we go back to either the original topic or something related closely thereto. .. .. However, I am also keeping this thread open with the understanding that we stop with the personal attacks and insults. ..
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.
The Administration Will Not Censor Speech Just Because It Is Uncomfortable Date of Precedent: 24 January, 2026. Thread Name: women with the chubby cheeks (Archive, Elten English Community)
Context: The user danielsalatek created a thread to hype up women with, as he put it, "chubby cheeks". Sir-Charlie made a joke in post 2, referencing his signature which at the time said "Hamas must be destroyed". In post 3, danielsalatek responded, continuing the joke stating that the gift of women's chubby cheeks should be used to destroy Putin, Hamas and the Islamist regime of Iran. Several users expressed outrage and reported im. In post 16, Sir-Charlie ruled that the Administration will not moderate based on the unpopularity of an opinion voiced by a user, particularly if the opinion referenced a public group or figure. He further wrote that the main function of the Administration is to moderate behaviour that is actively harmful, dangerous or illegal. AS an addendum to the above, Sir-Charlie did note that free speech does not, however, give a user the opportunity to make contravercial statements purely to be provocative and to gain shock factor.
Relevant quotes:
.. Rule 1 specifically states that we encourage frank discussion, no matter if the opinions shared may be uncomfortable to some. And we affirm that view. .. .. It's not the staff's responsibility to moderate how people respond to an opinion or take they disagree with, our responsibility is to moderate behaviour that's actively harmful or illegal. .. .. That being said, controversial discussions and conversations are fine, however being edgy just to-if you'd permit me to use a Trinidadian expression-'provoke a scene' is heavily frowned upon. The idea of frank discussion is to genuinely learn something new and gain an appreciation for points of view that may differ from your own, not to irritate and ragebate others just for lols. .. .. Now, make no mistake. If specific groups of people are targeted, we won't hesitate to step in based on the situation before us, however; the people mentioned in post 3 are public figures. Mr. Putin, the government of Iran and Hamas are all public entities. Being public figures, especially controversial ones necessarily unfortunately, raises the vitriol tolerated in comments and criticisms about them. ..
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.
Free Speech Does Not Extend To Personal Attacks Date of Precedent: 24 January, 2026 Thread Name: women with the chubby cheeks (Archive, Elten English Community) Context:
The user danielsalatek created a thread to hype up women with, as he put it, "chubby cheeks. He made several posts regarding public figure which drew the ire of several users. In response to criticism for his rhetoric, he made inappropriate comments regarding fellow user Arctic Moon. In Post 16, Sir-Charlie Ruled that, while his posts critiqueing various regimes across the world were protected under the forum's free speech provisions, no such protection exists for the desparraging of a fellow user based on personal characteristics.
Relevant Quotes:
.. The calculations in moderating posts 11 and 13 were less complex. Both very clearly fall into the category of harassment, a lack of civility, personal attack territory and demeaning to our fellow community member Arctic Moon. These posts are not OK, especially the implications made about her physical attributes and body. They are inappropriate... .. .. ...Harassment of any member on this forum will not be tolerated. ..
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.
The Administration Will Take Into Account Post History When Determining Appropriate Punishment Of a User Date of Precedent: 9 April, 2026 Thread Name: putting fingers on the girl's or women's knees (Archive, Elten English Community) Context:
After several months of inactivity, danielsalatek created a thread where he discussed a scene where he put his fingers on an at the time 16 year old girl's knee, seemingly without consent. The thread devolved to danielsalatek accusing persons criticising him for the distasteful post of being trolls, or derailing his thread. Sir-Charlie Ruled in post 29 that danielsalatek was to be banned for 6 months due to a consistant pattern of inappropriate and bizarre content. He further wrote that based on his post history, it had been assessed that his contribution to the forum were minimal, if not harmful.
Relevant Quotes:
.. Unfortunately, Daniel resurfaced, continuing an unacceptable pattern of inappropriate, absurd and bizarre content. .. .. This thread, together with the chubby cheeks one were riddled with nonsensical rage bate posts from Daniel. This suggests that he's either creepy, a troll, or a distasteful combination thereof. .. .. We have deemed his presence to contribute minimal value to the community; contrary, it actively harms the forum. ..
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.
The Administration Places Higher Urgency Into Rule-4-Violations of Fellow Forum Members Rather Than Persons Unknown To The Forum. Date of Precedent: 19 April, 2026 Name of Thread: what is something that heavily bothers you and makes you feel broken. (General Discussion, Elten English Community) Context: The user Ferre created a thread asking fellow forum users to outline things that are emotionally or mentally taxing to them. In his opening post, he revealed several personal and traumatic details about his girlfriend and fellow forum member, ButcherVanity. ButcherVanity later revealed that she was unaware Ferre would be discussing her personal issues publicly, and expressed dissatisfaction therewith. Sir-Charlie observed in post 24 that he had invoked Rule 4 previously in regards to Danielsalitek however, he noted that Daniel mentioned someone's name in passing and who was not a member of the forum. By contrast, Ferre had gone beyond simply name dropping, instead posting detailed intimate traumas of ButcherVanity. Sir-Charlie ruled that the Rule 4 violation in this case had been elevated due to ButcherVanity being an active participant of the forum.
Relevant Quotes:
.. This is a unique case because, while I previously dealt with a rule 4 violation in the case of Daniel Salatek, he had revealed the name of someone who, to my knowledge, is not an active member of the community, and the violation in that case only extended to the young lady's name. This situation is peculiar insofar as ButcherVanity is an active member of this community, and the violation extended beyond a simple slip of the finger in referring to an old friend by their name. .. .. And, this wouldn't be an issue if you...B, controlled yourself and didn't tell a story that was not, is not, and will forever remain, not your story to tell... ..
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.
Rule 4 (Privacy) Extends Beyond Personally Identifiable Information Date of Precedent: 19 April, 2026 Thread Name: what is something that heavily bothers you and makes you feel broken. (General Discussion, Elten English Community) Context: The user Ferre created a thread asking fellow forum users to outline things that are emotionally or mentally taxing to them. In his opening post, he revealed several personal and traumatic details about his girlfriend and fellow forum member, ButcherVanity. ButcherVanity later revealed that she was unaware Ferre would be discussing her personal issues publicly, and expressed dissatisfaction therewith. Sir-Charlie intervened in post 24, ruling that, while a strictly textual interpretation of Rule 4 would suggest that it only covers Personally Identifiable Information (PII), that view is a dangerously narrow one. He wrote that user privacy extends to the right to control any aspect of a forum member's life they wish to publish or remain private.
Relevant Quotes:
The OP, in detail, lays out ButcherVanity's triggers, past relationship traumas and even lays out present cleavages in her relationship with Ferre. Some of the details are traumatic and unfortunate to hear. Perhaps serving as an unwanted reminder of what was left behind, while others may be embarrassing to Butcher, as demonstrated by some comments in this thread. .. .. And, this wouldn't be an issue if A, you had sought her permission to post those details, B, controlled yourself and didn't tell a story that was not, is not, and will forever remain, not your story to tell... .. .. My invocation of Rule 4 was, frankly, more purposive in nature. A strict reading of the text suggests that the rule exclusively covers personally identifiable information. (PII) However, that interpretation is, also given the wording of Rule 4, naively and dangerously narrow. .. .. The purpose of the rule is to protect a user from having their privacy violated. Privacy isn't only about your data and dictates from Brussels, rather, privacy is about one's dignity and right to control what they share, or choose not to share about themselves. .. .. Whether someone's phone number is leaked or I write a post about another user accidentally pooping in our sleeping bag-never mind we were sleeping together in the bag-does not minimise the impact of the violation on the user's privacy. ..
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.
The Administration As Far As Possible, Will Attempt To Minimise Censorship While Maintaining Forum Cohesion Date of Precedent: 19 april, 2026 Thread Name: what is something that heavily bothers you and makes you feel broken. (General Discussion, Elten English Community) Context: The user Ferre created a thread asking fellow forum users to outline things that are emotionally or mentally taxing to them. In his opening post, he revealed several personal and traumatic details about his girlfriend and fellow forum member, ButcherVanity. ButcherVanity later revealed that she was unaware Ferre would be discussing her personal issues publicly, and expressed dissatisfaction therewith. In Post 24, Sir-Charlie issued a warning to Ferre and denounced him for the privacy violation. At the same time, he reiterated the forum's long-standing policy of minimising censorship where possible, however he said that extraordinary circumstances may require some level of censorship. As a compromise, he set the precedent that the offending material will be removed, while leaving the overall thread intact, and the Administration will make any instance of post redaction known.
Relevant Quotes:
From Post One: .. ..
The following posts are from Post 24 .. I have said on multiple occasions that I do not believe in censoring the body of a post unless extraordinary and peculiar circumstances call for such measures. I believe that protecting another person's privacy would be one such condition which falls under those extenuating conditions. .. .. I will also be removing the offending material from post one, but this thread will remain open because it has the possibility to remain interesting and constructive. ..
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.
This site uses cookies to enhance your experience.