Administrative Announcements & Discussion/Feedback

I Think We Need a Community Failure Clause

Started by Sir-Charlie 36 posts last post 5 months ago Closed Page 1 of 2

#1

The rules were never meant to be set in stone. The idea was that from time to time they may be updated by us, together, as a community.
Now, at the end of the rules, there is a clause that basically says that someone can be punished for something not specifiaclly written about in the rules, and that is pretty broad, but still flawed in some ways. I think we've seen that some people are obviously problematic, but I can't really do anything about it because they haven't specifically broken any rules.
But then, the question is, how do w introduce a system that's fair and involves community participation? We can't call it Community Failure or what have you when only 3 or so people out of the community makes the decision.
Also, I wasn't voted as moderator, and Simter won 41% of the vote, so we don't have a overwhelming democratic mandate either.
So, this is what I have in mind.
The moderators notices that someone is problematic and needs to be removed. One member of the team drafts a comprehensive document outlining why they're problematic, complete with specific examples and detailed reasoning.
Then, the moderators vote on th issue. Afterwhich, the document is published in a discussion thread for 7 or so days, possibly less. Let's say 4 maybe. Then, afterwards, a poll s created.
There are 2 conditions for a person to be banned under this system.
A, they get 25 people in favour of them being banned. This is approximately 66% of everyone whovoted in the last moderator poll, which is the largest voter turnout we saw since the first election with Arctic Moon, Marc, Simter and they,
Or,
B, they get 66% of everyone who voted in that particular poll.
Whichever is higher.
Also I think Community Failure, as a name shouldn't be used. I propose we call it Community Vote of None Confidence or something like that.
But anyways, what are your thoughts? This is just my thoughts. I'd like to hear your proposals if any, or any other rules you think I may have missed or rules that need to be updated.
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.

#2

Yeah, I agree that we don't need to call it community failure, because in a way, that sounds somewhat harsh. But I'm not sure what the nicest thng to call it would be.
Let the stars be your guide. Let your mind just relax. And when in doubt, meditate.

#3 3 likes

It's overthought. If you're a mod, just ban people who deserve it.
Reading all the time about people who should get banned, while you're not sure and the whole community has to discuss and vote on it — sorry, but no. It will become annoying in the end.
We chose people who should decide about bans, even if some decisions aren't easy.
Zapraszam osoby posiadające piesy, lub chcące je posiadać, do dołączenia do grupy o psach przewodnikach.

#4 Edited

In my oppinion, it's not up to us to decide who gets banned or who doesn't.
It's the admin's/moderator's choice.
It could turn out okay, but what poster 3 said, isn't wrong either.
Even if something isn't clearly written out in the rules, there's always basic norms that some people, have clearly broken.
Vox tech, trust us.

#5

Exactly, although we all know how things went before, so I'm not sure how well that'll work out this time, because this community has gone through a whole mess.
Alex Chapman (Alexoloopios)

#6

I've read only the title, so read this comment based on that. We truly need something, but not a Jayde style community failure clause, thanks but no thanks. It literally grants you all rights to ban anyone for anything if you don't like someone's face and it's not welcomed here. If you want a dictatorship, apply for a position on audiogames.net, you'll have more luck there.
Until Elten's security problems aren't fixed, a community failure clause won't help either. What stops for example me from creating another account if you ban this one because you don't like my opinion? What stops me from installing a VM if they ban me by HWID? What stops me from using Adguard or any vpn services to get around the ban? It's not the forum, but a low-budget klango alternative with a very fragile and non-functional moderation system.

Όταν θα κοιτάς την θάλασσα
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα βλέπεις εμένα
Και τα μάτια σου θα ‘ναι θλιμμένα
Όταν θα ξυπνάς στον ύπνο σου
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα σκέφτεσαι εμένα
Και θα νιώθεις μεγάλο κενό

#7

Nothing stops you, but should we stop banning anyone just because technically, bans can be avoided? Per that principle, bans shouldn't exist at all because there's no truely save system.

#8 Edited

@6, go read the first post.
@3/4, yeah but I address that directly inpost 1. I was never elected to be the Admin of this place and Karmien was like 2 votes away from losing to None of These Candidates, of all things.
So yeah, I can ban whoever I want, providing the reasoning is sound, but I rather not.
I think removing someone from the community should be a decision taken by the community as a whole, not just by a couple of people.
Again, if someone very clearly breaks the rules, then sure, I ban them, but what about the edge cases?
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.

#9 2 likes

@8, nothing. As an admin, you should do it.

I can ask my friends to vote against my ban, but if I don't like someone, I could also ask my friends to vote for banning that person.

It's the same problem, but you just want to say: "Ah, this situation isn't clear, so maybe the whole community should decide whether someone has to be banned."

That's not a solution.
An
d





t

h



e

































Zapraszam osoby posiadające piesy, lub chcące je posiadać, do dołączenia do grupy o psach przewodnikach.

#10

Agreed with Balteam. You are overexaggerating it and you have an audiogames forum sindrome.

Όταν θα κοιτάς την θάλασσα
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα βλέπεις εμένα
Και τα μάτια σου θα ‘ναι θλιμμένα
Όταν θα ξυπνάς στον ύπνο σου
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα σκέφτεσαι εμένα
Και θα νιώθεις μεγάλο κενό

#11

This whole thing reminds me of said forum, which is why I've only browsed, not interacted on there.
Alex Chapman (Alexoloopios)

#12

yeah I agree, people voting for this is not cool. its up to the mods if they should ban, having the community vote on this stuff gets out of hand

#13 1 like

No, we're not the ones to vote, the responsibility is with the person who took up the role of an admin/mod and I'm afraid, you should just execute it. If it is within reason, nobody will mind it.
Senter San

#14

I mean fine, but nobody is actually discussing an appropriate policy going forward to make sure the staff doesn't abuse the system. I won't be around forever, and maybe I might get drunk some day and may decide to ban Butcher Vanity on a whim. I mean, who knows?
Basically all what I'm saying is, I'm willng to accept the responsibility now that I actually have a mandate to do so, but there needs to be a clear policy in doing so.
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.

#15 3 likes Edited

That’s an exaggeration. There have been issues of this sort in the Polish community, and there’s no perfect solution, but if you wait for the community’s verdict, the forum will be spammed.
A simple example: I could start provoking and annoying you from now on in such a way as to get round the rules. How long would I actually cause harm for? There’s no room for ‘think about it for 4–7 days’ when it comes to banning. Either do it straight away, or nothing will change and it’ll be a mess.
Sorry for not ideal translation, i''m sleepy.
If the community is to decide on bans, what do we need an administrator for? Is the administrator just here to look good?
Sygnatura to może być w sądzie. Sygnatura sprawy np. :P

#16

If you do that, it’s entirely your problem – and it reflects badly on you. No one else’s. If your team abuses its power? Then they – and you too – are responsible for it, because you allowed them to use moderation tools.
-- (Sir-Charlie):
maybe I might get drunk some day and may decide to ban Butcher Vanity on a whim. I mean, who knows?

--
Sygnatura to może być w sądzie. Sygnatura sprawy np. :P

#17 1 like Edited

One last thing, which I actually find quite amusing:
You stood for the role of administrator. I won that time, but you were only a few votes short of winning.
Now you’re saying you’re not sure if you can do anything because you weren’t elected by the community. What difference does it make? You’re an administrator. If you’re afraid to take action, just resign. There’s no middle ground.
Let’s recall the recent issue with one of the users who posted inappropriate content involving minors. We waited a month for a response. In the end, even the council of elders had to step in. Do you still think surveys are a good idea? There’s no time to wait here. Either do your job, or don’t do anything at all.
Sygnatura to może być w sądzie. Sygnatura sprawy np. :P

#18

We'll never understand this Daszek. It's this typical american mentality about democracy which never worked anyway but they are trying hard.

-- (daszekmdn):
That’s an exaggeration. There have been issues of this sort in the Polish community, and there’s no perfect solution, but if you wait for the community’s verdict, the forum will be spammed.
A simple example: I could start provoking and annoying you from now on in such a way as to get round the rules. How long would I actually cause harm for? There’s no room for ‘think about it for 4–7 days’ when it comes to banning. Either do it straight away, or nothing will change and it’ll be a mess.
Sorry for not ideal translation, i''m sleepy.
If the community is to decide on bans, what do we need an administrator for? Is the administrator just here to look good?

--

Όταν θα κοιτάς την θάλασσα
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα βλέπεις εμένα
Και τα μάτια σου θα ‘ναι θλιμμένα
Όταν θα ξυπνάς στον ύπνο σου
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα σκέφτεσαι εμένα
Και θα νιώθεις μεγάλο κενό

#19

At least he doesn't just decide on randomly having enough, stepping down shortly after making an application, looking at you arctic, or just giving adminship to someone who clearly has several issues he's dealing with and who's not ready for such responsibility in the slightest.
Sorry to say it, but yall shouldn't speak as bouldly as you do now. I don't see any accomplishment that makes those claims and reactions stand.
Es hat sich ausgekaschpatt.

#20

If you have carefully read through the situation of me stepping down, it was everything but not random. I clearly told the community about the fact that I'm not ready to help a project that has political views I'm not engaging in. I'm not supporting regional restrictions and I'm not ready to give up my beliefs, just because someone alone dictates it from above. And well, I'm studying to be a translator, not to be a kindergarden teacher.

Όταν θα κοιτάς την θάλασσα
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα βλέπεις εμένα
Και τα μάτια σου θα ‘ναι θλιμμένα
Όταν θα ξυπνάς στον ύπνο σου
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα σκέφτεσαι εμένα
Και θα νιώθεις μεγάλο κενό