Administrative Announcements & Discussion/Feedback

I Think We Need a Community Failure Clause

Założony przez Sir-Charlie 36 wpisów ostatni wpis 5 miesięcy temu Zamknięty Strona 2 z 2

#21 1 polubienie Edytowano

If you’re mentioning me as well, I stepped down after a long time because it seemed the community wasn’t ready for proper moderation; there were no people with the energy to co-moderate, and the forum was a huge, unmanageable mess.
And as you can see, I stepped down due to various factors, and haven't problem to inform why when i did it. So I don’t see anything wrong with my post.
So just moderate and take responsibility for everything, or not moderate. There’s no middle ground.
Sygnatura to może być w sądzie. Sygnatura sprawy np. :P

#22

See? You're already looking down on all of us again. I just don't get your whole picture of thinking you're superior, though then having been an admin for years, only to reapply as a mod under dash's rule to then step down. Why were you mod in this time in the first place?
-- (ArcticMoon):
If you have carefully read through the situation of me stepping down, it was everything but not random. I clearly told the community about the fact that I'm not ready to help a project that has political views I'm not engaging in. I'm not supporting regional restrictions and I'm not ready to give up my beliefs, just because someone alone dictates it from above. And well, I'm studying to be a translator, not to be a kindergarden teacher.

--
Es hat sich ausgekaschpatt.

#23

I didn't target you with the point I targeted Arctic with, rather the fact that you with no hezitation handed this place into the hands of, quite simply, childish behaving and unexperienced people, which, acording to you years of experience make out a good admin.
-- (daszekmdn):
If you’re mentioning me as well, I stepped down after a long time because it seemed the community wasn’t ready for proper moderation; there were no people with the energy to co-moderate, and the forum was a huge, unmanageable mess.
And as you can see, I stepped down due to various factors, and haven't problem to inform why when i did it. So I don’t see anything wrong with my post.
So just moderate and take responsibility for everything, or not moderate. There’s no middle ground.

--
Es hat sich ausgekaschpatt.

#24

I never said I was handing this place over to specific people who behave childishly. Point them out to me, because so far all I can see is that you have an issue with Arctic, and that’s probably what you mean.
Paulinux (Co-moderator) moderated the Polish community for two years. He’s a brilliant moderator.
DJSenter lived in the UK and was best placed to understand different ways of expressing oneself, and he also moderated the EN community a few years earlier.
Others applied and their applications seemed sensible.
So I don’t understand why my experience is being questioned. Besides, that’s not what this thread is about.
Sygnatura to może być w sądzie. Sygnatura sprawy np. :P

#25

I think I know what you meant now.
The problem was that I had no one to hand it over to. No one else came forward. On top of that, I didn’t have any support from the council of elders regarding the appointment of a new team of moderators, etc., so I did what I could. It was better to have some moderation than none at all
Sygnatura to może być w sądzie. Sygnatura sprawy np. :P

#26

No no, I think he means Alex Chapman.

-- (daszekmdn):
I never said I was handing this place over to specific people who behave childishly. Point them out to me, because so far all I can see is that you have an issue with Arctic, and that’s probably what you mean.
Paulinux (Co-moderator) moderated the Polish community for two years. He’s a brilliant moderator.
DJSenter lived in the UK and was best placed to understand different ways of expressing oneself, and he also moderated the EN community a few years earlier.
Others applied and their applications seemed sensible.
So I don’t understand why my experience is being questioned. Besides, that’s not what this thread is about.

--

Όταν θα κοιτάς την θάλασσα
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα βλέπεις εμένα
Και τα μάτια σου θα ‘ναι θλιμμένα
Όταν θα ξυπνάς στον ύπνο σου
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα σκέφτεσαι εμένα
Και θα νιώθεις μεγάλο κενό

#27 1 polubienie Edytowano

Actually I disagree on that stance. The time Pajper had it somehow was more peaceful and less troublesome.
-- (daszekmdn):
I think I know what you meant now.
The problem was that I had no one to hand it over to. No one else came forward. On top of that, I didn’t have any support from the council of elders regarding the appointment of a new team of moderators, etc., so I did what I could. It was better to have some moderation than none at all

--
Es hat sich ausgekaschpatt.

#28

I mean both. It turned into Jacob as mod, then admin, and from that point he felt like giving it to chappers.
-- (ArcticMoon):
No no, I think he means Alex Chapman.

-- (daszekmdn):
I never said I was handing this place over to specific people who behave childishly. Point them out to me, because so far all I can see is that you have an issue with Arctic, and that’s probably what you mean.
Paulinux (Co-moderator) moderated the Polish community for two years. He’s a brilliant moderator.
DJSenter lived in the UK and was best placed to understand different ways of expressing oneself, and he also moderated the EN community a few years earlier.
Others applied and their applications seemed sensible.
So I don’t understand why my experience is being questioned. Besides, that’s not what this thread is about.

--

--
Es hat sich ausgekaschpatt.

#29 1 polubienie Edytowano

Yeah I'm getting mixed signals here. First, without actually reading my proposal you accused me of moving towards being a dictator. Then, when you actually read it, the complaint is that this is too much freedom, and went off on a bizarre rant about Americans (Which I'm not for the 23RD time BTW) and liking democracy too much. I mean, this is stupid and dumb, but you do know the concept of democracy emerged in Europe, right? Which is it?
Or, is it neither, and this is only "Bash Charlie just cuz"?
All that I survey, I could easily destroy. From time to time, it is important to remind these small creatures of the true extent of my power.

#30

I know you aren't american, I never even said you are. It's just something they love so much.

Όταν θα κοιτάς την θάλασσα
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα βλέπεις εμένα
Και τα μάτια σου θα ‘ναι θλιμμένα
Όταν θα ξυπνάς στον ύπνο σου
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα σκέφτεσαι εμένα
Και θα νιώθεις μεγάλο κενό

#31

Isn't relevant in his case.
Es hat sich ausgekaschpatt.

#32

Yk I hate to say it, but at this point I feel like public comunities are going downhill anyways. While not being relevant exactly, I still wanna put it here because it would prevent a lot of harm. What? Well, simply to put the group on request to join. Maybe sounds stupid, but even on ag.net which most here use apparently, you got account varification stuff. This would be at least something.
Es hat sich ausgekaschpatt.

#33 Edytowano

Imagine account verification on Elten. You create a spam account using a throwaway email address which is active for 10 minutes. It's just enough time to receive an email from Elten, verify your account and continue spamming. If there was yet another verification step that would involve the admins too, you either would never get in, or the situation would be the same since the admins can't check IP addresses.
Scenario 1: the admins are so inactive they don't even notice the fact that someone registered so you would never be able to be a part of the community.
Scenario 2: the admins notice you registered, but since they know just the same information about you as a regular user, they aren't able to fact-check who you are. They
a. Tell you that they are bringing your case to the team and it never will be solved since these are usually just words and they aren't taking anything anywhere,
b. They unrestrict you with no hesitation and hooray you can continue spamming.
Based on that, I wouldn't say public communities are going downhill overall, I'd rather say the same about blind public communities. Because we just don't need them.

Όταν θα κοιτάς την θάλασσα
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα βλέπεις εμένα
Και τα μάτια σου θα ‘ναι θλιμμένα
Όταν θα ξυπνάς στον ύπνο σου
Χωρίς να το θέλεις, θα σκέφτεσαι εμένα
Και θα νιώθεις μεγάλο κενό

#34 2 polubienia

I'd rather you be a dictator, as long as you follow the commonsense rules, which you had in mind when forming this community as I remember. They're were and are quite loose and permissive as they are, so you can step in and warn and better yet, ban problematic users. Problematic meaning not someone who disagrees with you, or expresses views which you don't like, but does it in an insulting, outright hostile way, for example. It's not so hard to ban trolls and delete posts which are talking about the troll trolling and give a good example to the community, than letting mess cover fun, creative and interesting posts.
Senter San

#35

"Democracy is a soft variant of communism... rarely in the history of ideas has it been taken for anything else."
- Hans Herman Hoppe
Chesterton, G.K. "When men choose not to believe in God, they do not thereafter believe in nothing; they then become capable of believing in anything."

#36

34
Unfortunately, everyone defines common sense differently. I tried administering on common senses behalf a few times and everyone has a different opinion abot it.
Besides, you guys are making a lot of contradictory points here, as charlie pointed out.
I am not sure about community voting about bans either, how ever it would solve the dictatorship issue.
greatings, Felix, alias Karmien

Mastodon: @randomfelix@dragonscave.space
WhatsApp: +4915560642152
Discord: felixius2084